972-836-7750 Request a demo Talk to an expert
Talk to an expert Request a demo Call sales 972-836-7750

Learning Center

EDI comparisons

Side-by-side comparisons of the choices EDI teams face most often, with clear trade-offs and guidance on when each option fits.

Which comparison answers your question?4 decision questions, each linking to the comparison that answers it: how should files travel securely (AS2 vs SFTP), portal or erp integration (web EDI vs integrated EDI), who should run the edi work (managed EDI vs in-house) and where should the platform run (iPaaS vs on-premises).Which comparison answers your question?Start from the decision you need to makeHow should files travel securely?AS2 vs SFTP: signed receipts and push delivery, or simpler batchtransfer.AS2SFTPMDNPortal or ERP integration?Web EDI vs integrated EDI: typing into forms, or documentsflowing into your ERP.Web EDIERPWho should run the EDI work?Managed EDI vs in-house: control, staffing risk and cost.In-houseHybridManagedWhere should the platform run?iPaaS vs on-premises: the provider’s cloud, your data center, orboth.CloudOn-premisesHybrid
Which comparison answers your question?4 decision questions, each linking to the comparison that answers it: how should files travel securely (AS2 vs SFTP), portal or erp integration (web EDI vs integrated EDI), who should run the edi work (managed EDI vs in-house) and where should the platform run (iPaaS vs on-premises).Which comparison answers yourquestion?Start from the decision you need to makeHow should files travel securely?AS2 vs SFTP: signed receipts and pushdelivery, or simpler batch transfer.AS2SFTPMDNPortal or ERP integration?Web EDI vs integrated EDI: typing intoforms, or documents flowing into your ERP.Web EDIERPWho should run the EDI work?Managed EDI vs in-house: control, staffingrisk and cost.In-houseHybridManagedWhere should the platform run?iPaaS vs on-premises: the provider’s cloud,your data center, or both.CloudOn-premisesHybrid

Pick the question closest to your decision and select it to open that comparison. Each one gives a direct answer first, then the trade-offs side by side.

Expand diagram Download SVG

  1. Managed EDI vs in-house EDI: cost, risk and control

    How running EDI yourself compares with managed EDI and hybrid models, and how to decide which fits your organization.

    Read

  2. Web EDI vs integrated EDI: which is right for your business?

    How browser-based web EDI compares with EDI integrated into your ERP, and when it is time to move from one to the other.

    Read

  3. AS2 vs SFTP: choosing a secure protocol for B2B file exchange

    How AS2 and SFTP differ in security, delivery proof and operational effort, and which to use for EDI and file exchange.

    Read

  4. iPaaS vs on-premises EDI software: how to choose

    How cloud iPaaS compares with on-premises EDI software, and when a hybrid deployment makes sense.

    Read

How to use these comparisons

Most EDI decisions are not about which option is better in general, but which fits your partners, volumes, systems and team. Each comparison sets out how the options work, what each costs in effort and risk, and the signals that point to one or the other.

  • Standards and connectivity: which EDI standard and which transport protocol your partners need.
  • Operating model: who runs EDI day to day, and on whose platform.
  • Deployment: cloud, on-premises or hybrid, and how that affects control and upkeep.

Many organizations combine options, for example integrating high-volume partners while keeping smaller ones on web EDI, so a comparison is a starting point for a design rather than a final answer.

More comparisons in EDI fundamentals

Compare ECOM delivery models

Talk to an integration expert

Tell us about your partners, systems and goals. We will show you how PRISM and our team can help.

Request a Demo Contact us